Story Transcript
INVESTIGACIÓN DIDÁCTICA
!""#"$%$'#&()(!'*#+$,'$)#-!.#$/(.#01/($ 23"3$.3$-(-4&*(&3$-!$.3$&(!'&(3 Vallverdú, Jordi5 6 Izquierdo, Mercè7 !
"#$%&'(&)$*(+",$"-./+0+12&3"4*.5$'0.(&("67(8*+)&",$"9&':$/+*& "#$%&'(&)$*(+",$"#.,+',.35&//5$',7?7&@3:&(3" )$':$3.AB7.$',+?7&@3:&(3 ;
Resumen. C/"%'$0$*($"&'(2:7/+"$D%/+'&"/&"7(./.,&,",$"7*"*7$5+")+,$/+",$"&*+'" :+)%'$*0.K*",$"/&"%'$(.5+03"C/"%'.)$'+"$0"&L7,&'"&"/+0"&/7)` :&)@.+0"'&,.:&/$03" *+0"&"S&:$'"7*&"/$:(7'&"%'+17*,&",$"/+0"($D(+0"$*"/+0"B7$"0$" C*" *7$0('+" .*($*(+" %+'" +1'$:$'" 7*" )+,$/+" :+S$'$*($" '$!"$'$*":+*('+5$'0.&0":.$*(2!":&0M",$")&*$'&"B7$":+)%'$*,&*" ,$" :+)%'$*0.K*" ,$" /&" ,.*$(.5+0":+/$:(.5+0M"$/$)$*(+0M"(+` U.*M"!aead"F&A7'M"!ab!d"C*N$/S&',("$("&/3M"!abeM"9'&*($" ,+0"$//+0M"B7$".*""7L$*"$*"$/",$0&''+//+"($:*+:.$*(2!":+3"C/"0$` $("&/3M"!aaZGM"B7$"$0"$/"+'&'"/&0",.*+'"/&":+)%/$>.,&,",$/"&7/&" ]+'"(+,+"$//+M"$/")+,$/+"F6#.="07%$'&"$*1+B7$0"%'$` ,$":.$*:.&0"L"/&"N'&*":&*(.,&,",$"1&:(+'$0"B7$":+*:7''$*" 5.+0"$*"/+0"B7$"0$"07%+*2&"B7$"g$/")7*,+",$"/&":.$*:.&"L" $*"$/"%'+:$0+",$"N$*$'&'"$5.,$*:.&0"$D%$'.)$*(&/$0":+*` 070")+,$/+0".*($'%'$(&(.5+0h"L"$/"g)7*,+",$"/+0"5&/+'$0" 5.*:$*($0M" 0$'$" EFQS$7(" L" ]0.//+0M" @.$*",.1$'$*:.&,+0M"*+",$@2&*")$A:/&'0$M"L"B7$"%&'&",$` ;YYc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squema básico del Modelo de Análisis de la Dinámica Científica B7$"Q0(+0"S&*",$"'$/&:.+*&'0$":+*"$/"%'+@/$)&"EB7$"0.$)` (MADiC). %'$"$0":+)%/$>+G"B7$"/+0"S.A+"07'N.'"L":+*"/+0":'.($'.+0"B7$" /+"S&:$*"5&/.+0+"$*",$($').*&,&0":.':7*0(&*:.&03"]+'"$//+M" $0"*$:$0&'.+"%/&*($&'"0.(7&:.+*$0"$0%$:.&/)$*($"'$/$5&*($0" %&'&"%/&*($&'"%'$N7*(&0".*($'$0&*($0"B7$"*+"(.$*$*"7*&"'$0` %7$0(&"O*.:&"0.*+"B7$"'$B7.$'$*"!"*&/)$*($"(+)&'"7*&",$:.` 0.K*"0+0($*.,&"%+'"&'N7)$*(+0"@.$*"17*,&)$*(&,+03" C*"$0($":+*($D(+"L":+*"$/"+@>$(.5+",$"('&@&>&'"/&":+)%/$` >.,&,",$"/+0"%'+:$0+0"B7$":+*0(.(7L$*"/&"&:(.5.,&,":.$*(2` !":&M"0$"%'+%70+"7*"$0(7,.+",$":&0+["$/",$@&($"$*('$"]&0` ($7'"L"]+7:S$("&:$':&",$"/&"N$*$'&:.K*"$0%+*(K" ,$" )&*$'&" E,.0%&'G"$*"/+0"$0B7$)&0",$"/+0"&/7)*+0M"%$').(.$*,+":+*0` (&(&'" ,.1$'$*:.&0" 0.N*.!":&(.5&0" $*('$" /+0" ,.0(.*(+0" N'7%+03" C0(+"*+"'$0(&"5&/+'"&/")+,$/+"0.*+"B7$M"&/":+*('&'.+M"%+*$"$*" $5.,$*:.&"/&".*""7$*:.&",$"/&"1+')&:.K*"%'$5.&"$*"$/",$0&''+` //+"%$'0+*&/",$"7*")+,$/+":+*:$%(7&/",$":.$*:.&3
G,6,)%4'-&'$)9,1'6,$)+,2%+#H%()%I ;J%?)J7I))+,$) 1,$) -)1')+%)*#1%)90'1')$'()'$9,-&Q-'%. %(4CMI)+,$)'@9'(#6'-&,$)'$&Q-V-,)'$&Q-)7#'-)('%+#H%1,$. %(4CPI)+%)('$90'$&%)%+)%(4CJ)1%)%+%$V=('-%)+%)9'($9'2*%)'*,+02#,-#$&%. %(4CRI)'+)'*,+02#,-#$6,)'$)#-6,(%+.
^&0"'$0%7$0(&0",$"/+0"&/7)*+0M"&02":+)+"$/"%'+)$,.+":+*` :$%(7&/",$"070"$0B7$)&0"F6#.=M"17$'+*"/+0",&(+0",$"*7$0` ('&".*5$0(.N&:.K*M"L"07"&*$)%/+M")&*.1$0(&'+*"7*"N'&*" '$:S&A+"S&:.&"$/"($D(+"!"/+0K!":+"E$/"F6#.=G"L"17$"*$:$0&` '.+",$,.:&'"7*&"0$0.K*",$":/&0$"&"/$$'/+":+*",$($*.).$*(+M" ,.0:7(.'/+"L"//$N&'"&"5&/+'&'"070"&%+'(&:.+*$0d"0K/+"7*+",$"/+0" $0(7,.&*($0M"B7$"S&@2&"'$&/.A&,+"$0(7,.+0",$"!"/+0+12&",$"/&0" :.$*:.&0M"%&'$:.K":+)%'$*,$'/+",$")&*$'&"&7(K*+)&3"]7,.`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cGM"%%3"!`;c3 6JPI^-VM"m3]3"E!aaeG3"Yd'(('0(?)0-),0+)9,0()'-$'#4-'(?)]&'20["CJ-3
9IHV^M"m3"L"]4mI^M"X3F3"E;YYbG3"C/"%&'&,.N)&",$"/&":+)%/$` >.,&,M"7*")&':+",$"'$1$'$*:.&"%&'&"$/",.0$R+",$"7*".*0('7` )$*(+",$"$5&/7&:.K*",$"%'+N'&)&0",$"1+')&:.K*".*.:.&/",$" %'+1$0+'&,+M"U-$'A%-H%)1')+%$)G#'-2#%$I)('*#$&%)1')#-*'$C 4%2#>-)5)'@9'(#'-2#%$)1#1Q2%$M";\E!GM"%%3"k`;;3
96=IHM"-3"E!\;YG3"],*06)b(4%-063
9X6HPCM"P3"L"-4^^CXM"J3"E$,03G"E!aaZG3"G,-&(,*'($#%+)O2#C '-2')Lf(,6)G,-&'-&)&,)G,-&'-,-FM"4J6["J(&($"4*.5$'0.(L" +1"Hn3
9CXfJIHM"W3"L"WCPPCXJCH"E!abcG3"Y'%(-#-4)=(,6)U((,(I) e%(&)B,99'(d$)B$523,+,45),=)Y'%(-#-4M"^&"J&//$M"V^["I%$*" =+7'("]7@/.0S.*N"=+)%&*L3
=I^^VHJM"o3"L"]VH=oM"P3"E!aa\G3"U+)4>+'6.)Y,)-) 1'+)9(,='$,(%1,?"!M"%%3"!Z`Z\3"6''&L$:(03"WS$*" (&U.*N" .*(+" &::+7*(" (S$" .*""7$*:$" +1" &//" B7$0(.+*0"&*,"%'+%+0$,"(S&("(S$L"T+'U"+7("&*0T$'0"70.*N" (S$0$"1&:(+'0".*"(S$"$)$'N$*:$"+1"U*+T/$,N$M"(S$"0:.$*:$" (S$" F6#.=" )+,$/3" J+)$" N'+7%0" %'+5.,$," F6#.=" ($&:S$'"S&0")+'$"'$0+7':$0"(+":+//&@+'&($"T.(S"%'+1$00+'0" N'&%S.:0M" &0" T$//" &0" T'.(($*" &*0T$'03" -'+)" (S$0$M" T$" T.(S.*"+(S$'"&'$&0".*"+',$'"(+"('&.*"%$+%/$"T.(S"(S$":'.($'.&" :&*" .*1$'" (S&(" &/(S+7NS" (S$'$" &'$" 0.N*.!":&*(" ,.11$'$*:$0" &*," :&%&:.(L" (+" )&U$" ,$:.0.+*03" PS.0" )+,$/" :+)@.*$0" @$(T$$*" (S$" (S'$$" N'+7%0M" (S$" 5&/7$" +1" (S$" )+,$/" .*" .(0" 0$5$'&/" 0+:.&/" N'+7%0" E0:.$*(.0(0M" ,.00$).*&(+'0" +1" &%%/.:&(.+*".0"*$5$'(S$/$00"'$.*1+':$,3"I*$"+1"(S$"'$07/(0" U*+T/$,N$M":.5./"0+:.$(LG"T.(S"5&/7$0"E$%.0($).:"+'"(S+0$" '$5$&/0" (S&(" %'$5.+70" $,7:&(.+*&/" @&:UN'+7*," S&0" &" '$/&($,"(+"=%2&$M"&*,"*+*`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`,.'$:(.+*&/" -+'"&//"(S$0$"'$&0+*0M"T$"$5&/7&($"(S$"'$07/(0"+1"(S.0"!"'0(" '$/&(.+*0S.%"TS$'$.*"@+(S"&N$*(0"@$*$!"(")7(7&//L3" &(($)%("&("(S$"&%%/.:&(.+*"+1"(S$"F6#.=")+,$/"%+0.(.5$/L3" PS.0" )+,$/" &//+T0" 1+'" (S$" )7/(.`1&:(+'.&/" &*&/L0.0" +1" V*" +',$'" (+" 0(&'(" T.(S" &" 0%$:.!":" $D&)%/$M" T$" 70$," &" 0:.$*(.!":" &:(.5.(L" &*," (S$" &%%'+%'.&($" :+*0.,$'&(.+*" +1" S.0(+'.:&/" :&0$[" (S$" ,$@&($" @$(T$$*" ^+7.0" ]&0($7'" &*," (S$"$''+'0"%'$0$*(".*".(3"PS$":+))+*"T+'U"+1"&"0:.$*:$" -$/.D`6':S.)Q,$"]+7:S$("&@+7("0%+*(&*$+70"N$*$'&(.+*3" %S./+0+%S$'"&*,"&"0:.$*:$",.,&:(.:0"%'+1$00+'"S&0"+%$*$," 9'.$""L[" .*" !bkb" ]+7:S$(" @$N&*" (+" %7@/.0S" (S$" '$07/(0" 7%"*$T"T+'U.*N"%$'0%$:(.5$0"(S&("T$z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y(S$" 0&)$z" $D%$'.)$*([" 7*,$'0(&*,.*N"+1"0:.$*:$"&0"T$//"&0"(S$"&%%'+&:S"(+"(S$" (S$L"%7(").:'+0:+%.:"1+')0"+1"/.1$".*"0+/7(.+*0".*"0$&/$," %'&:(.:$"+1"0:.$*:$".(0$/1"E+*"&*"$,7:&(.+*&/"/$5$/G3
60
ENSEÑANZA DE LAS CIENCIAS, 2010, 28(1)