Story Transcript
WoW Industry
QSR Industry : Amongst highest Consumer growth + Top Quartile RoC
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
QSR Industry : Offers highest terminal value, given demographically aligned
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Addressable population ~40-50crs of the total India amongst the highest population density in the world India has highest Population / Store, thus significant room for growth
QSR Industry : Build in Metros ; Scale & Cashflows beyond Metros
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Beyond Metros, Tier I – II III offer significant growth potential with much better unit economics
QSR Industry : Store density far from maturity
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
QSR Industry : Significant distribution in the works
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Almost ~14% CAGR on store rollout next 3years itself highest in B2C Industry (struggling for double digit growth )
QSR Industry : Even within entrenched city, store density to increase
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
All QSR’s roll out multiple store formats OR split stores within larger radius, to increase through put
DELIVERY Duo FRIEND OR FOE ! : Distribution vs Margins Food Aggregators
Restaurant Chain
Increasing Coverage
Improved Penetration
Higher Promotion
Recruited New Consumers
Higher Supply
Increased Competitive Intensity
Rise in orders
h c r a e s e
Q e
V
u l a
Aggregators Commission 18-25%
R t s ue
Differential Pricing
Restaurant Margin 10-20%
1. New Channel has opened up 2. Higher Cost for Consumer 3. Large QSR Chains are better off over smaller players
Rise of Food Aggregators, Negotiation tug-of-war
a e s e
2019
2020
2021
31 Mn
191 Mn
403 Mn
239 Mn
28K
94K
143K
148K
Monthly Transacting Users
1 Mn
5.6 Mn
10.6 Mn
6.8 Mn
AOV
Rs. 436
Rs.282
Rs.278
Rs.397
500+
R t s ue No. of orders
Q e
200
u l a
15
V No. of cities Source: Zomato RHP
h c r
2018
Metric
Active Delivery Restaurants
QSR Industry : Food Delivery Duo, adding to demand Chinese + FF + Pizza + Burger = Zomato 30% & Swiggy 24%
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
QSR Industry : Demand, Price vs Margins equation
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
QSR Industry Ecosystem far complicated than visible, E.g. JFL Value chain
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
QSR Industry Ecosystem : Key Building blocks (E.g. JFL)
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
QSR Industry Ecosystem : Key Building blocks (E.g. JFL)
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
QSR Industry Ecosystem : Key Building blocks (E.g. JFL)
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Jubilant Foodworks (Dominos) h c r – McDonald's of India ea
s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
EVOLUTION OF DOMINO’S IN INDIA 4,500
1600
4,000
3,500
Period
Revenue CAGR
2001-2020
28%
2010-2020
15%
Launch of Every Day Value
3,000
t s ue
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
Launch of Rs. 35 Pizza Mania
Launch of the ‘30 minutes or free’ campaign
500
2
100 34
38
93 48
-
155
Launch of Online ordering
Q e
u l a
V 109
1,335 3,927 1,360
236
313
1,414
3,018
3,312
2,438
1000
2,583
2,093
800
1,736 600
1,019
400
678
476
200
0
1996 FY01 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY20 FY21 Consolidation Source: Company
1200
1,026
Launch of BOGO 726
3,563
465
307
181
e R
a e s
h c r
1,117
1400
Planned Growth
Aggressive Growth
Momentum Continues
DOMINOS – A FOOD TECH COMPANY!! ➢ Considerable upgradation in India app → Driving majority of orders through their app ➢ Retain last mile delivery edge even for orders emanating from aggregator platform ▪ Own customer’s delivery experience ▪ End up paying lower commissions to aggregators
h c r a e s e
➢ No other QSR company has been able to achieve this level of success in digital which is the next big growth driver for the Industry
u l a
Q e
V Source: Company
R t s ue
App
Rating
Downloads
Domino’s
4.5
70 Mn+
Mc Donald’s
4.3
50 Mn+
Pizza Hut
4.2
1 Mn+
KFC
3.7
10 Mn+
Burger King
3.4
1 Mn+
Growth Variables I : High Growth Phase FY10-FY16 Stores 306 –to- 1,097, 3.6x ; No. of Cities 69 –to- 235, 3.4x 1,200crs of Capex, 12-14%/Sales ; Revenue per store increased from 1.2-1.4 –to- 2.3, 70%+ increase Outcome : Revenue 5.7x i.e. 34% CAGR
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Growth Variables II : Growth vs Operating Leverage Whatz noticeable is no major change in Gross Margins & decline in Ebitda Margins, due to growth cost & Inflation impact Yet 26% Ebitda CAGR vs Revenue CAGR 34% (Negative operating leverage)
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Growth Variables III : Business Mix Non-Pizza contribution has increased from 21% in FY11 to 27% While Gross Margins & Ebitda margins have inched up last 5yrs, yet no concrete evidence if Non-Pizza contribution was a source of increase
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Growth Variables IV : Cost Structure No major change , within tight bands across time periods
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Capital Efficiency I
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Capital Efficiency II
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Growth Variables V : Leadership vintage
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Most of the leadership team seems relatively new
10 > 8yrs ( Of which 5 nearly 20yrs at firm )
Product Innovation a constant treadmill..
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
DOMINO’S – DIVERSIFICATION OR DIWORSIFICATION? ✓ Dominos India has achieved a decent scale and profitability.
h c r a e s e
✓ It has become a strong cash throwing machine over the last 4 years. (Annual cashflow is ~400Cr and Capex requirement is ~200Cr)
R t s ue
✓ Domino’s has strong unit economics in place with cash payback period well under 3 years – cashflow machine to enhance further !!
Q e
✓ All new ventures have large market in place with no national player.
u l a
✓ If executed well, these brands can really scale up fast.
V
✓ WE BELIEVE, THIS IS A STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION
QSR Frameworks
R t s ue
Q e
V
u l a
h c r a e s e
Building blocks to evaluate
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Cuisine a key Building blocks to SCALE
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Royalty rates : Franchisee RoIC top quartile despite… Will no royalty be a competitive advantage for home-grown !
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Unmatched Trifecta :
Healthy Payback period + High Incremental RoIC + Ability to deploy large capital
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
WHAT DO WE GATHER? ➢ Restaurant Industry is highly fragmented and largely unorganized in India.
h c r a e s e
➢ Globally, we have seen that large QSR chains having more than 70+ yrs of history have grown consistently and continue to dominate the market. ➢ Rapid adoption of Western Fast-Food Culture, favorable demographics, urbanization and rising income levels provide QSR companies a huge runway for growth in India.
R t s ue
➢ While it is easy and profitable to run few outlets in a city/region but very difficult to scale up the brand nationally given dynamics of India – varied food preferences, lack of standardization etc.
Q e
➢ We’ve realized that QSR is a game of throughput per store. Throughput per store → Healthy unit economics → Reinvestment at a higher rate. Therefore, with healthy throughput & product value proposition in place, Scale has no limits.
u l a
V
➢ QSR is a cash throwing business with negative working capital requirement. Due to strong cash flow generation, a company can easily support its own growth without hurting the balance sheet significantly.
QSR COMBINES BEST OF BOTH THE WORLDS A Retail Company’s RUNWAY for growth + FMCG Company’s NEGATIVE WORKING CAPITAL
h c r a e Globally Listed Restaurants / QSR s e R Only 77 listed cos >$500mn t s e u Q e u l a V
QSR Developed World
Despite QSR being a large Industry in West, mere 27 listed peers (>$500mn Market Cap)
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Dominos (4 listed cos, ~$22bn Market Cap.) Growth is scarce
Dominos clear grower ( USA, Australia & Britain ) Only 4 cos ~20% growers
QSR Emerging World
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Market Cap. China ~$46bn India ~$7.4 Thailand ~$4.4bn
India Returns ahead of the pack India & China > Avg. Valuation : Avg P/S 4.4x ; 30x EV/Ebitda ; 40x P/CF
Nasdaq vs QSR (Amongst the rare segment to match the former in returns)
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Change is gradual, then sudden I – Devyani Int. MCap. 25k crs
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Change is gradual, then sudden II – WestLife Foods MCap. 12k crs McD & Dominos both entered India 1996 ; McD lags at ~3k crs revenue vs Dominos ~4.4k crs
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
Listed India QSR & Food Cos QSR Range : EV/Ebitda 25-35x
Food Range : EV/Ebitda 20-30x
h c r a e s e
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue
There is only one of a kind • McDonalds : Tried Pizza Late 80’s for 10years, gave up by late 90’s https://www.passionateinmarketing.com/case-study-mcdonalds-pizza-what-could-possibly-go-wrong/
h c r a e s e
https://www.businessinsider.in/retail/news/the-rise-and-fall-of-mcdonalds-pizza-a-doomed-fast-food-icon/articleshow/79465817.cms https://bettermarketing.pub/what-led-to-the-failure-of-mcdonalds-pizza-75de0e7b1fbd
V
u l a
Q e
R t s ue